
I’ve come to the conclusion that the essence of writing fiction is simply asking ourselves the question, ‘What if?’, and then letting our imaginations run riot for a while.
Abstract impressions floating around our heads are all very well but it’s that ‘What if?’ that is is the creative ball we need to get rolling in order to move further.
Have a wild think about some of these without worrying too much where they take you and resist the urge to reign yourself in or be realistic for just a few minutes:
What if my dog started talking to me?
What if my bicycle turned into a tank?
What if I woke up one morning, and I couldn’t see anything?
What if I went to the supermarket and found it was entirely populated by hamsters?
What if my toaster started transmitting messages from outer space?
What if I found a body buried in the garden?
What if, what if, what if… That’s the starting point for everything. The possibilities are endless. Curiosity is our watchword. That’s one reason why children are so good at going along with a story and asking unexpected questions. They are fascinated by all that life reveals and are not yet bound by the restrictions of logic.
There are already plenty of very good books out there with vivid descriptions and excellent plot structures: novels which give us a sense of normality; settings and characters that are as familiar as old friends, and there’s comfort in reading that sort of book. But the most exciting books ask that all important, ‘What if…’ question and follow it down a path of inquiry that allows our imagination to take a leap into another world.
If you can think of something a little less run-of-the-mill as you ponder that ‘what if’, then so much the better. Allow a thought to develop beyond the usual sticking point; let your imagination run free.
What if my wallpaper came to life?
What if my plants started eating nothing but pasta?
What if my goldfish escaped?
What if I fell down a drain?
What if I had three wishes from a genie?
What if my friend turned out to be an alien?
What if I discovered a secret door/treasure map/family album
What if my fairy godmother appeared and transformed my circumstances?
What if I found a way to travel through time?
What if I could suddenly understand other languages?
What if I uncovered a plot to kidnap the Royal family?
What if…?
What if, what if, what if?
The question provides a wonderful diving board into fresh writing spaces – the evocative mental trampoline from which everything else can emerge.
Perhaps you’re not planning on writing fiction, in which case you can choose to push all this aside. But, if you’ll indulge me for a moment, you may find that your abstract thoughts and daydreams bend themselves in this direction. As we hunker down for the winter months with those long, dark evenings, let’s allow our thoughts and ideas to flow and see where they take us: down a rabbit hole, through a time warp, into a war zone, out of reality, away from civilisation, onto a boat, through a mirror, up in a flying machine, back to your childhood…
So many stories yet to be written if we allow ourselves to be taken there. Happy writing to you all!
NB: This article first appeared in an expanded version in Writers Narrative eMagazine on Substack in March 2026. [ https://substack.com/home/post/p-186059610 ]
Image from Pixabay

Jenny Sanders has spent the last fourteen years living between the UK and South Africa. She writes faith-inspired non-fiction: Spiritual Feasting (2020) asks how we can ‘feast’ when life serves unpalatable menus; Polished Arrows (2024), explores the allegory of God shaping us to be fired effectively into our culture and contexts.
Jenny also has two published collections of humorous short stories for Key Stage 2 children: The Magnificent Moustache and other stories, and, Charlie Peach’s Pumpkins and other stories. Her new book will be available in Spring 2027.
She is available for author visits and creative writing sessions in primary schools. She loves walking in nature, preferably by a river, and has a visceral loathing for offal, pineapple and incorrect use of car indicators on roundabouts.


Really good, Jenny. Thought provoking. I’m looking at dogs on my walks now, wondering which one(s) are going to say ‘Mornin’ and stroll on ????
That’s brilliant! So glad, John. Let that imagination fly… who knows where it might take you (and maybe us too)!