August 7, 2026

It’s a strange thing, but I do get a kick out of being grumpy. Perhaps that’s why One Foot in the Grave’s Victor Meldrew of old was so popular?

One of the several things that can fire up my inner ‘I don’t believe it!’, is online requests for reviews for trivial purchases, such as suncream or candles.

And then…pause for writerly reflection…I find myself asking for feedback on my writing. Why? What is this all about?

I’m not pretending to know the answer. Wiser heads, psychoanalysts, spiritual advisers, and the like might well be able to peer under this particular bonnet and make sense of the workings of the soul.

All I can offer is an inkling.

And that inkling, I believe, is an act of discernment.

Of course, it’s lovely when someone comes up to you and says, ‘I loved your book…’ and you can see from their demeanour this is genuine, not simply politeness. Magic. But I suspect, as writers, we also want some, at least, to go beyond gushing praise or crushing criticism.

We are looking for ‘constructive criticism’. Why? Because, like any other skill, we can only deconstruct our impostor syndrome by constructing a greater understanding of our craft, gleaning from others how to develop our writing.

So, I’m using this post to give three recent examples of receiving negative comments that spurred me on, rather than holing me below the waterline:

  • ‘Your extended metaphors are compelling but…over explained, reducing their capacity to unsettle or surprise…let these images begin to work as natural feeling revelations’
  • An early criticism of draft 1 of novel: ‘information dumping’
  • ‘A lovely suggestive poem, full of delicate atmosphere but partially marred with opacity…clarify your thinking – who, what, where.’
  1. I can see the science-teacher in me, the left brain, desperate to be heard…to explain, to inform, to ensure that no stone is left unturned, to be thorough. Rather than leave clues, to invite curiosity, to permit exploration. By deliberately not colouring in but giving readers a few crayons.
  2. Similar. This was a shock. A surprise. But once recovered, I realised I needed (still do) to make a conscious effort to take readers into the emotional tides and thinking of each character. To balance character with plot. I now use a character development sheet to help me keep on track. I naturally remember the plot, not characters.
  3. Yep. I do love creating a certain degree of opacity and ambiguity. I know what I’m doing. Sometimes, for example, camouflaging very personal reflections in obscure imagery. I’ve been caught out! I’m mid-contemplation on this criticism – wondering if the answer is, in part, to be more open, to take risks, and stop hiding…

Psychoanalyst I am not. Rookie writer? A good friend suggested I read Ken Follett. Such a good idea; I’m currently reading The Evening And The Morning and can immediately see that I have yet to come close to mastering some of the skills he seems to employ effortlessly. But I’m enjoying the chase…most days.

I’m not sure how to ‘circle back’ (a phrase I would gladly ban from use if I had a magic wand) to One Foot in the Grave, except to say, it would take someone braver than I to employ Victor Meldrew as a beta reader…though his comments would, no doubt, keep the rest of you highly amused!

was no longer words but song

John Stevens

Website: www.unlessaseed
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61556515267762
Novel: The Bait Digger – a historical spy novel set in 1796  https://www.amazon.co.uk/s?k=the+bait+digger&i=stripbooks&crid=3I4IYW4NA3CN&sprefix=%2Cstripbooks%2C98&ref=nb_sb_ss_recent_1_0_recent
Non fiction: When the Rabbis Cry – a biblical and historical exploration of Israel post-resurrection  https://www.amazon.co.uk/When-Rabbis-Cry-John-Stevens/dp/1512753750

 

By John Stevens