A lad from the
tribe of Sheeran was recently brought before the city elders. The sons of
Marvin claimed he had stolen parts of a psalm attributed to their forefather. Believing
that he had earned much gold, the sons of Marvin were angered and wanted
retribution.
The
Sheeranite – a ruddy lad with a particular gifting in stringed instruments and a probable
descendant of Jubal1 made his
case with all the townsfolk watching and listening closely. Much music sounds
like other music. There are only a certain number of ways things can be done.
The sons of
Marvin, however, maintained that he knew what he was doing, and was therefore a
liar. Some in the crowd needed fine details explaining, such as the difference
between a lyre and a liar. Truth be told, it would not be clever to harp on about
it.
The elders
considered the facts and decided in favour of the Sheeranite. You could not
subtract the facts. He composed his own psalms, even when they occasionally sounded
similar to other psalms.
It put me in
mind of a separate case, where the clan of Samuel were offended when they
discovered that lyrics from a song their ancestor Hannah had written had been stolen.
The tune could not be verified, but the case was strong for the words. The
original song had been composed to mark a poignant moment in the life of a
mother who had finally had a son and had given him to serve God.2
The plagiarised version involved an unmarried girl from an inconsequential
region who had fallen pregnant and written a song about her excitement, despite
her circumstances.3
The
parallels between the two versions are extraordinary, and the family of the
clan of Samuel made the following case to the authorities:
* Both songs begin with the singer
glorifying the Lord;
* Both explain that the Lord is unusually
holy;
* Both relate examples of retributive
justice from God toward the proud and self-reliant;
* Both describe how the Lord lifts
up the humble and the hungry;
* Both talk about the
extraordinary scale of God’s justice.
When this
case went before the elders, the young woman who stole the lyrics was
represented by a distant family member, a priest called Zechariah. He raised
his voice repeatedly in court until he was heard. When the crowds fell silent,
he explained that Hannah may not have composed the song entirely herself either.
Referencing Psalm 113, he pointed out many similarities there too. I’m just
thinking out loud, he said, but women have been singing in this style
for centuries. They often sing when they go about their daily tasks, such
as repetitive flour grinding, weaving, spinning and working in the fields. They
love to copy tunes they have heard.
Perhaps his
young relative was not wrong to copy the style or to reference such a poignant
and powerful moment in cultural history. Although she did not earn gold or silver
for her song, her story bears consideration and the parallels between the women’s
lives and their sons may also warrant closer inspection.
Zechariah
went on to sing a similar song himself, but by this point many of the crowd had
made their own minds up and left. Maybe creative inspiration was about to run wild…
1. Genesis 4:21
2. 1 Samuel 2
3. Luke 1




