Image by mcmurryjulie from Pixabay
I hope, once that author is over the shock of the attack (because that is essentially what it is) they will eventually come to see the up side.
Yes, far too many one-star reviews are just dumb: either plain missing the point or blaming the author for something that isn’t even their fault. Publishers and authors must tear out their hair when, for example, a book gets a one-star review because it arrived later than the customer hoped for, or got knocked about in the post. That is not the author’s fault and nothing to do with the quality of the book.
In the latest edition of The Author, however, Mark McCrum makes a couple of very valid points about one-star reviews.
One is the sheer entertainment factor. I enjoyed coming across a review of The Hiding Place that complained it got too religious at the end. My novel The New World Order, set during the English Civil War, drew a complaint that I was using it to push my Catholic agenda. A clear sign that reviewers that shouldn’t use long words they don’t understand; I’m not a Catholic, but Catholicism was, let’s say, in the air quite a lot in that period.
In short, they can be just so wrong, there’s no point getting upset.
But McCrum also makes another point: that they can be much more informative than the puffed-up four- and five-star ones. Fans who truly love an author’s work might not be very critical; neither, probably, will be the author blurbs festooning the cover. A one-star review might genuinely point out the flaws and reveal the Emperor’s new clothes.
I know, this can be cold comfort, and as I say, a malicious review like the one that started me off here is an attack. A blow when you have already made yourself vulnerable hurts twice as much. The Society of Authors has a page of health and wellbeing resources for authors that could come in very handy: https://www2.societyofauthors.org/help/health-wellbeing/.
And meanwhile: “Blessed are you when people insult you, persecute you and falsely say all kinds of evil against you because of me …”
Ben Jeapes took up writing in the mistaken belief that it would be easier than a real job (it isn’t). Hence, as well as being the author of eight novels and co-author of many more, he has also been a journal editor, book publisher, and technical writer. His most recent title is a children’s biography of Ada Lovelace. www.benjeapes.com




