April 3, 2026

 

This year Good Friday
falls on April 03rd which is actually quite fortunate given its my turn on the
blog this month. I first wrote this piece some four years ago not long after becoming a regular blogger on this site. It was originally published in
our local Methodist circuit monthly devotional newsletter which started during Covid when
our churches were closed and who lacked internet access 
and still continues to this day.

My reason for writing it
was to show that in the age of modern media which all of us especially Christian writers have to adapt to especially with ChatGPT and AI
now part of the mix, I wondered had the internet been around in first
century Palestine how the events of that first Good Friday may have been
recorded for posterity especially from Pilate’s perspective. 

It is based on John
18:28 – 19:16 (NRSV)
.

.Context: When we read this version
of Christ’s passion, we can almost feel ourselves becoming caught up in the
action. Are we among the crowd who having been whipped into a frenzy by the
Chief Priests and Pharisees, demanding Jesus be put to death for blasphemy in
exchange for the release of a known murderer and criminal named Barabbas? Or
are we among those of Pilate’s staff who possibly witness the exchange between
Pilate, Jesus and the crowd outside his headquarters? Or are we among the
soldiers who carry out the scourging at the pillar and who then mock Jesus by
putting him in a purple robe and placing the crown of thorns on his head and
hailing him as King of the Jews? What about Pilate himself, what was possibly
going through his mind during these exchanges? In Luke’s account he takes to
consulting Herod as Jesus is a Galilean, and in Matthew’s gospel, Pilate’s wife
makes a brief appearance warning him to
“Have nothing to do with this innocent man, for
today I have suffered a great deal because of a dream about him”.
Whichever account we
choose to accept, Pilate as representative of the emperor Tiberius, was tasked
with ensuring law and order in Judea which was subject to sporadic outbreaks of
violent resistance by Jewish Zealots, who favoured violent overthrow of roman
rule in Palestine. Given the political and religious sensitivity of the
Passover, it is quite likely that Pilate took the path of least resistance when
faced with an angry crowd calling for Jesus’ crucifixion. In this scenario this
is how Pilate might have recorded the events of that first Good Friday.

 Jerusalem,
Judea, The Passover, AD29

 They came early
this morning dragging some poor wretch with them who they accused of blasphemy
against their God. Their God, whose laws prevent them mixing with non-Jews, to
prevent ritual defilement just so they can eat their Passover meals. It comes
to something when the representative of Rome must go outside as if being
summoned, to then face a mob and be asked to pass judgment on someone who may
not even have committed any offence. When I asked them to specify the
accusation against the man – a Galilean – they replied, “If he were not a
criminal, we would not have handed him over to you”.

 When I
challenged them to judge him instead according to their law, they responded
that they were not permitted to put anyone to death. All of which is true, but it
seems somewhat expedient that they have already in their minds decided on his guilt,
yet want me to be the executioner!

 Given the
agitated nature of the mob I summoned the prisoner inside and proceeded to
question him by first asking him directly, was he King of the Jews? His
immediate response was to enquire if I asked this for myself or did others tell
me about him? Not being a Jew I have no idea who this man really is but wanted
to know why his own people had handed him over to me. His answer was somewhat
perplexing, “for his kingdom is not of this world” he said. If it were, his
followers would be fighting to keep him from being handed over to the Jews, but
as it is, his kingdom is not one that we would readily understand. “So, you are
a King”, I asked him trying to establish a rationale for is behaviour. “You say
I am” he replied, but he maintains he was born and came into the world to
fulfil a destiny – to testify to the truth and those who testify to the truth
listens to his voice. “What is truth?” I reply, not really expecting a coherent
answer.

 Yet again I say
to the waiting crowd outside that I find no evidence or case against this man
but as it is the custom of the time, I am willing to release someone, some
criminal or subversive. When I ask if I should release the King of the Jews,
the crowd – clearly influenced by their leaders – demand the release of the
bandit called Barabbas. I ordered the prisoner to be flogged by way of
punishment for being a public nuisance. The soldiers determined to humiliate
him further, press a crown of thorns to his head and dressing him in a purple
robe so they might mock this self-proclaimed king of the Jews. I present this
pathetic figure of a king to the crowd to show that he is no more than a man,
another itinerant troublemaker who this God of theirs seems to attract, but who
has committed no offence for which he should be condemned to death. Once again,
the crowd angrily demand he be crucified for blasphemy for it is their law he suffers
death for claiming to be the son of God.

 This gives me
some concern as our rule in Palestine depends on the co-operation of the local
elite, so I go inside and ask the Galilean where he was from? Receiving no answer,
I tell him that I have the power of life and death over him, to release or to
crucify. Once again, his answer perplexed me. He said, “You would have no power
over me unless it had been given to you from above; therefore, the one who
handed me over to you is guilty of a greater sin.”

 Clearly this man
has stirred Jewish emotions, each time I try to release him they become even
louder and more agitated to the extent they may riot. They even claim that to
release him would be seen as unfriendly to the emperor himself.

 Given
Jerusalem’s prominence within empire and its history, can I really afford to
risk this situation getting out of control and word getting back to Rome which
may see me recalled or even replaced? If I give in to their demands and give
him over to crucifixion will this placate them? Is the life of one man a price
worth paying to ensure stability during this important festival which means so
much to the Jews not only from Jerusalem, but across Palestine as a whole?

 I bring the
Galilean outside and the crowd once again demand his death. I sit on the stone
of judgment and ask the crowd, “Shall I crucify your King?” The crowd respond,
“we have no king but the emperor”. This settles the matter and having
symbolically washed my hands to show the matter is concluded in their favour, hand
the prisoner over for crucifixion.

 Later however as
I write this, I wonder what it is that makes a man behave the way this man did?
What is it about their God that makes people act the way they do? Was he really
who he claimed to be, or was he just another itinerant blasphemer – Palestine
appears to be full of them. I suppose we will never know, like all threats to
our position it had been dealt with efficiently and permanently and normal
service seems to have been resumed.

 I doubt we will
hear any more about it!

Footnote: As writers our grounding in Holy
Scripture – in whatever genre we prefer to express ourselves – forms the basis
of our craft. Modern media can be a two-edged sword, but by putting these stories into such a context, I feel goes a long way to a better understanding and explanation
because as we know the Bible, particularly the Gospels, are known more for what
they don’t tell us than what they actually do at times.

 As we approach the season
of Easter once again, let us pause to remember its true message. How the
barbaric killing of an itinerant preacher from Nazareth was not the end, merely
the beginning of what was and still forms the central tenet of the Christian
faith; the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ which gave rise to the
promise of new life in him which continues to this day and continues in turn, to
inspire us in our own devotional lives.

Michael Cronogue originally
from London still resides in Walsall in the Black Country region of the UK.
Writer and blogger discussing matters of faith and theology on his
website 
www.michaelcronogue.com . He holds a Bachelor of Arts in Theology from the
Queen’s Foundation Birmingham, and is a Methodist Local Preacher serving
various churches in the Black Country area, as well as a visiting preacher in
parts of North and Southeast Cornwall.  

By Michael Cronogue