March 21, 2024

 

Generated cartoon image of wooden person holding saw, with books, chairs, tools, gavels

I am in the processing of reworking editing my
manuscript. The last time my editor saw me she asked, ‘Lucy, are you a
madwoman, architect, carpenter or judge right now?’

Thankfully, this was not in any way meant to insult me.

‘I am probably at all of these at the moment,’ I said. But
it got me thinking. We both knew what she was talking about. Some years ago, we
both attended an ACW event in London where Amy Boucher Pye had given a talk on
this topic, originally taken from Betty Flowers’ famous 1981 article: ‘Madman,
Architect, Carpenter, Judge: Roles and the Writing Process’. If you’ve not yet
come across this theory, or missed the talk, the key points are that when you
are writing you may hit a wall if you try to wear too many hats at once. The
optimal order for progress is:

1.      
Madwoman / Madman Ideas stage: let loose
and unleash your creativity.

2.      
Architect Form stage: select content and
arrange at paragraph level thinking.

3.      
Carpenter Sequence stage: sentence
structure, clarity, logic and grace.

4.      
Judge Critic stage: analyse, proof and
check details.

When my editor asked me which stage I was at, we both
instinctively knew that this is a genuine issue I have. My madwoman shouts
loud, but my inner judge usually shouts louder. Judges can interrupt and kill
creativity. In my case, genetics and education have given me an eye for a typo
and I constantly need to focus on the creative and structural processes. On bad
days, my inner judge is quite mean, but over time she has also become my
friend. I’m the repeat offender on first name terms with the magistrate, rolling
our eyes together at my latest writing mistake.

My madwoman is often dancing in the background too. How do I
keep her happy? I write ideas down. I indulge her occasionally. Embrace a bit
of nonsense. If God can create duck-billed platypuses duck billed platypi
giraffes, I have permission to think outside the box too.

Writing practice means that the forming and sequencing
stages need not be too painful or drawn out. And I would certainly add that having
an open mind cushions the ego when changes need to be made.

Maybe, like me, you find it painful to finish a sentence
without checking for errs errors. You may also, like me, find it hard
just to wear one hat at a time. You might have written so many essays, articles
or chapters that you know how to jump to Carpenter stage, having had a super
idea you need to share with the world instantly.

That’s great. But perhaps there is still merit in breaking
your process down and allowing yourself to wear each hat one at a time.

1.      
Have I been creative enough? Is there more I
could or should bring to this piece?

2.      
Have I considered how to structure the overall
shape? Does it work?

3.      
Can I put over my writing beautifully and
clearly? Does it flow?

4.      
What faults can I spot and repair as I revisit
my writing, before it goes to a wider audience?

I am very grateful to Amy Boucher Pye for bringing this to
my attention and to my editor Amy Scott Robinson who reminded me of it. The method keeps me sane
and works as a useful checklist.

And now I am mostly at Judge stage. I do keep finding little
elements to tweak at a bigger level, but the process is organic and iterative
and that’s ok too. As long as I’m not wearing all of the hats, all of the time.

Lucy Marfleet

Lucy Marfleet loves reading, laughing, her husband’s
cooking, walking her dog and marvelling at how tall the kids are getting. She
teaches Biblical Studies for Spurgeon’s College on their Equipped to
Minister
course and has a Masters in Theology from the International
Baptist Theological Seminary. See her blog at www.lucymarfleet.com

Image created using Bing

Originally written by Lucy Marfleet