April 25, 2023
Image by rawpixel.com on Freepik

Just about every writer that I
know has struggled at some point with self-belief and imposter syndrome. 
So, how does it make you feel when you
receive negative reviews and feedback?

I was asked this question during a
recent interview for a popular literature Youtube channel, and this was my answer.

No one likes to receive negative
feedback of any kind, it can be painful and the hurt cuts deep.  You question why you bother.  These are all natural reactions but I have
given this a lot of thought.  I now say
that I would rather have negative feedback than no feedback at all.  When I receive nothing, it makes me feel
insignificant.

Another thing that I have realised
about negative reviews is that not all books will be to everyone’s taste and
liking, so you must expect some lower reviews. 
For example, my best-selling book has many 4 and 5-star reviews, but among
them is a 2-star with patronising comments.

I admit that I was a little taken
aback by this review, then when I weighed it up against all of the positive
compliments, I considered something else. 
Sometimes, it isn’t the book that is the problem, the problem lies with
the person reviewing it.

Apparently, the ‘sweet spot’ for
Amazon reviews is a 4.2-star rating, it is an indicator of genuine reviews.  My book that I am referring to currently has
a 4.6 rating, so I would welcome a few more 3 or 4-star ratings (but not too
many).

There are right ways and wrong
ways to leave a low review.  It is
possible to leave a good review of a book that you consider to be bad.  Consider these points when writing a negative
review.

1.      
Explain what disappointed you.

2.      
Don’t be personal and nasty.

3.      
Don’t patronise.

4.      
Consider what the author was aiming to achieve.

5.      
No spoilers.

6.      
Don’t forget to mention the good parts.

7.      
What would make it better?

8.      
Consider if other readers might enjoy it.

I digest every comment that I
receive, I take it on board and I learn. 
I am thankful for them all and appreciate the person taking the time to
communicate with me.  I would love to
hear your comments about this blog, for example.

So, how do you feel about negative
reviews?

 


Brendan
Conboy aka Half Man Half Poet
 is the author of 11 published books including his fascinating
autobiography, The Golden Thread.  In 1986, Brendan invited
Jesus into his life and God blessed him with the gift of rhyming words. 
He used that gift as a Christian Rap artist for 25 years and has written 5
poetry books including the entire Book of Psalms in Rhyme.  He
has 3 published novels – Issues, Invasion of the Mimics and Legacy of
the Mimics.  
He is the creator of Book Blest Christian book
festival.  Brendan is available for speaking events, poetry
performances and workshops.  Visit Brendan’s website HERE.

By Brendan Conboy